Delaforum

N e w s

 

Delaware Department of Transportation will hold a contest to determine what the new Tyler McConnell Bridge will look like. The unusual approach – this is the first time it is being done in Delaware – is not likely to eliminate controversy over the span, however. Before the competition can happen, a group representing transportation, business and civic interests in the area has to decide where it should go.

DelDOT is now forming an advisory committee to deal with that vexing question. If past history is any indication, that will be a poser because of the conflicting interests involved. The project was shelved a few years ago when an earlier advisory committee stalemated.

That won’t happen this time out, according to DelDOT external affairs 

spokesman Michael Williams. The current timetable calls for the preliminaries to be taken care of this year leading to actual construction to occur in the summer of 2002. It is estimated that the entire project will cost in the neighborhood of $73 million.

The bridge now carries a seven-day daily average of  23,000

Tyler McConnell Bridge as viewed from downstream.

vehicles. There is no available estimate of the obviously higher workday average.

DelDOT is under pressure to enlarge the bridge from its present two lanes to four to eliminate one of two bottlenecks remaining on Route 141 in order to accommodate the Astra Zeneca Inc. and Du Pont Co. Experimental Station expansions. The bridge links Barley Mill Road with Powder Mill Road, two of the principal approaches to the new corporate facilities.

The other 141 bottleneck – Ferris and Centre Roads between Prices Corner and Lancaster Pike – is not addressed in any current DelDOT plan.

Williams said there apparently are two viable options – tear down the present McConnell Bridge and replace it with a bigger structure, or add two lanes to the present structure. In either event, six lanes – the original DelDOT proposal – are out for the time being, but whatever is built now has to be expandable to that width some time in the indefinite future, he said.

He said a bi-level bridge is unlikely because of cost, the amount of ground its approaches would consume and engineering considerations, but he did not reject that idea totally. "We’re not eliminating any possibility so long as it doesn’t bust the budget," he said.

The advisory committee will reopen the old question of how to fit the bridge in without violating historical and environmental sensibilities.

The span crosses the Brandywine just south of Hagley Mills. Apparently not being considered a factor in the bridge planning process getting underway is the fact that Du Pont will be observing the bicentennial of its founding during 2002, the construction summer. The company built its first black powder mills at Hagley, which is now a museum and historic attraction.

It must be anchored to the steep east bank of the creek valley and many area residents are adamant that it does not disturb wooded areas or the tranquility of the valley at that point.

Du Pont also has maintained that dislocating the present Experimental Station fence would constitute a major hardship because the company’s federal Environmental Protection Agency air pollution permits are based on that alignment.

"This is probably the most sensitive project we have ever done," Williams said.

While not saying so in so many words, the previous advisory committee – many of whose members will be invited to be on the new one – seemed to conclude that it couldn’t be done.

Idea of the contest – a competition among engineering and design firms – is to remove esthetic considerations from the debate. At the same time, it is reasoned that approach will result in a design compatible with the area.

A "panel of experts" will determine the winning design, Williams said. The prize will be the contract to produce plans and manage construction.

"Normally, we put out the [specifications] in great detail and tell the contractor what to build. This time, we’re going to let them tell us what we should build," he said.

The closest the agency has come to that was in the construction of the sate Route 1 bridge over the Chesapeake & Delaware Canal. In that case, DelDOT paid for two complete designs. The one chosen and built has since won several professional awards.

Williams indicated that DelDOT would be more than happy if the long-standing McConnell Bridge controversy were eventually resolved with a bit of national recognition.

© 2000. All rights reserved.

WHAT DO YOU THINK?

READ RELATED EDITORIAL: Would a 'twin' McConnell Bridge work?

RETURN TO NEWSFRONT

GO TO MISCELLANY

GO TO HAPPENINGS

RETURN TO DELAFORUM COVER